Palisades zombie reactor action alert!

Yard signs created by Michigan Safe Energy Future's Kalamazoo Chapter and Shutdown Palisades Campaign.

Dear Friends and Colleagues,

For the second time in just three short weeks, the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) is holding a major public meeting in Benton Harbor, Michigan, regarding Holtec’s zombie reactor restart scheme at Palisades nuclear power plant. Palisades is located on the Lake Michigan shore in Covert Township, in Van Buren County, in southwest MI. The restart is unprecedented, unneeded, highly risky for health, safety, and the environment, and insanely expensive for the public. But Palisades’ zombie reactor restart precedent is already spreading to such other supposedly closed for good reactors as the infamous Three Mile Island Unit 1 in Pennsylvania (Unit 2 had a 50% reactor core meltdown on March 28, 1979), and Duane Arnold in Iowa (which had a near-miss with catastrophe in August 2020, after being hit by tornado force straight line winds). Diablo Canyon nuclear power plant in California also belongs on the would-be zombie reactor list: Unit 1 was supposed to close for good this year, and Unit 2 next year, but now CA Governor Newsom has done a 180, backed by the state legislature, NRC, and the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE, led by former MI governor Jennifer Granholm) — they are instead throwing billions of dollars at Pacific Gas & Electric, to extend Diablo’s operations indefinitely, despite off the charts earthquake, embrittlement, and other risks.

We need your help to nip this worsening nuclear nightmare of zombie reactor restarts in the bud at Palisades! Please attend this meeting, either in-person or online/telephonically. Please make verbal public comments/ask questions/express concerns. Please spread the word to your networks. The Great Lakes — 21% of the entire world’s surface fresh water — are at risk, due to this “game” of radioactive Russian roulette that Holtec, NRC, DOE, and government officials (elected and appointed) are “playing”! According to the Japanese Parliament’s independent investigation, just such collusion was the root cause of the Fukushima nuclear catastrophe. But frighteningly, we have such collusion in spades at Palisades!

For those who can attend in-person, NRC is holding an “open house” with posters beginning at 5:15pm ET. Be sure to check out Beyond Nuclear’s information tables in the hall/lobby outside the meeting room as well, at any point from start to finish. Also, please consider making public comments/asking questions/expressing concerns at the microphone — to do so, you need to sign up/in at NRC’s table on the way into the meeting room. Persons attending in-person will be given priority to speak, in the order in which they signed up/in.

But webinar/telephonic participation is also possible, and NRC will turn to those online/on the phone for public comments/questions/concerns as well.

Please see the NRC’s notifications, further down below, for the details on the in-person meeting location, as well as how to take part via webinar or by phone. Note that pre-registration is required for the webinar, at least a half-hour before the meeting begins, that is, by 5:30pm ET on Thursday, August 1st.

Please read on below for more information, take part in this meeting if you can, and spread the word to your networks. Thanks!

—Kevin Kamps, Beyond Nuclear
(240) 462-3216
TALKING POINTS YOU CAN USE TO PREPARE YOUR OWN COMMENTS/QUESTIONS/CONCERNS
In terms of potential comments you could review to prepare your own, see our coalition’s environmental scoping comments, written — and submitted to NRC just now, by the agency’s arbitrarily short 30-day deadline — by our co-legal counsel, Terry Lodge of Toledo, OH. Thank you very much to the 80 organizations, and 137 individuals, who endorsed these coalition comments!
Another comment could be expressing opposition to Holtec’s requested, so-called “Exemption,” which is actually a License Amendment in disguise, allowing the Palisades operating license, relinquished and terminated by previous owner Entergy on June 13, 2022, to simply be restored for Holtec’s use, to operate Palisades from August 2025 to 2031, which would mark 60 operational years at Palisades (1971 to 2031). Our environmental coalition already challenged this so-called “Exemption” last December, but was rebuffed by NRC, which argued we cannot intervene against an “Exemption.” Except, going from closed for good status, with no operating license, to fully operational again, is about the biggest License Amendment imaginable! It is NOT an “Exemption”!
Holtec has also begun the application process for an 80-year license at Palisades, from 2031 to 2051, so another comment could be opposition to that extreme license extension.
Another repository of information you can use to prepare comments/questions is Beyond Nuclear’s website, <https://beyondnuclear.org/>. Simply put <Palisades> in the search engine, and related posts arranged chronologically backwards will appear. This includes the past two years and three months of the zombie reactor restart nuclear nightmare, first floated by Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer on 4/20/22, a month to the day before Entergy closed Palisades for good. This also includes the nuclear nightmare of Holtec building two so-called SMR-300s (“Small Modular Reactors” of 300 Megawatts-electric each) at the Palisades site, and yet more at Palisades’ sibling closed for good reactor site, Big Rock Point in Michigan’s northwest Lower Peninsula. Holtec CEO Krishna Singh first floated the trial balloon of SMR new builds at Palisades just days before Gov. Whitmer floated the reactor restart scheme, in April 2020; Holtec then added Big Rock Point to the SMR target list on June 28, 2022, the very day it took over the Palisades and Big Rock Point sites from Entergy. Note that Holtec pulled a bait and switch trick, a con job. Holtec got its hands on both sites, under the pretense of decommissioning Palisades. But just one week later, on July 5, 2022, Holtec secretly applied to the U.S. Department of Energy for billions of dollars in bailouts, in order to restart Palisades instead.
Another search at Beyond Nuclear’s website could be for <Holtec>, to see more detailed information on the company’s long track record of incompetence, corruption, and even criminality.
For example, here is a recent two-page summary on Holtec, as well as related backgrounders on, prepared as part of the March 27, 2024 launch of the expanding podcast series, hosted by Roger Rapoport, “The Nuclear Reactor Next Door,” focused on Palisades:
Holtec has already gotten $1.8 billion in DOE loans and State of Michigan grants for the restart scheme, but this is just the tip of the iceberg. Holtec wants more than $8 billion, and still counting, in public bailouts for the restart scheme alone, and another $7.4 billion in DOE loan guarantees for SMR new builds on Michigan’s Lake Michigan shore. The grand total of public bailouts (from federal and state taxpayers, as well as ratepayers) sought by Holtec at Palisades and Big Rock Point now surmounts $15.7 billion, and still counting! These ratepayer and taxpayer ripoffs are fair game for comments/questions/concerns on Thursday as well.
NRC NOTIFICATIONS AND PRESS RELEASE
NRC Meeting Notification, as posted here <https://adamswebsearch2.nrc.gov/webSearch2/main.jsp?AccessionNumber=ML24200A204> and pasted in immediately below:
July 18, 2024
Title: HYBRID PUBLIC OUTREACH MEETING WITH THE U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION AND HOLTEC DECOMMISSIONING INC. ON THE POTENTIAL PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT RESTART
Date and Time: August 01, 2024, 05:15 PM to 09:00 PM ET
Location: Grand Upton Hall at Lake Michigan College, 2755 E. Napier Avenue, Benton Harbor, MI
Category: This is an Observation Meeting. This is a meeting in which attendees will have an opportunity to observe the NRC performing its regulatory function or discussing regulatory issues. Attendees will have an opportunity to ask questions of the NRC staff or make comments about the issues discussed following the business portion of the meeting; however, the NRC is not actively soliciting comments towards regulatory decisions at this meeting.

Purpose: The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff will discuss the NRC’s Restart Panel activities including licensing reviews and inspections for the Palisades Nuclear Plant potential resumption of power operations. Holtec Decommissioning Inc. (HDI) will discuss current and planned activities for the Palisades potential restart. The public is encouraged to ask questions about the NRC’s oversight pertaining to the potential Palisades restart.

Contacts:
April Nguyen
630-829-9587
[email protected]
Ngola Otto
301-415-6695
[email protected]
Justin Poole
301-415-2048
Participants:
NRC
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Region III
Office of Nuclear Material Safety and Safeguards
Office of Nuclear Security and Incident Response
External
Holtec International
Teleconference:
Bridge Number: (301) 576-2978
Conference ID: 110229600
Pass Code: 110229600#
Docket Number: 05000255
Comments: This meeting is hybrid (in person & virtual). The Open House will be held in person only from 5:15 PM to 6:00 PM ET, as it does not lend itself to the hybrid format. Members of the public, who are participating virtually can join the meeting at 6:00 PM ET. Register at least 30 minutes in advance of the meeting by clicking on the link provided above. The link will take you to a new page where you will be asked to provide registration information including an email address, so that the system can send the Microsoft Teams link for the meeting. You can also join the meeting by telephone using the…[this section seems to be cut off]…priority to speak during the public questions and comments session.
The NRC provides reasonable accommodations to individuals with disabilities where appropriate. If you need a reasonable accommodation due to a disability to participate in a meeting or need a meeting notice or the transcript or other information from a meeting in another format (e.g. braille, large print), please email [email protected]. Determinations on requests for reasonable accommodation will be made on a case-by-case basis and the agency may choose between effective accommodations to provide. At least ten (10) days advance notice is recommended in order for a request for accommodation to be processed and implemented if approved. However, every effort will be made to address any reasonable accommodations requests received with less notice.
PUBLIC MEETING AGENDA
HYBRID PUBLIC OUTREACH MEETING WITH THE U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION AND HOLTEC
DECOMMISSIONING INC. ON THE POTENTIAL PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT RESTART
August 01, 2024, 05:15 PM to 09:00 PM ET
Grand Upton Hall at Lake Michigan College
2755 E. Napier Avenue
Benton Harbor, MI
TIME                               TOPIC                                                                  SPEAKER
5:15 to 6pm ET               Open House                                                           NRC
6 to 6:15                          Welcome, Opening Remarks, Instructions            NRC Facilitator
6:15 to 6:40                     Holtec Presentation                                               Holtec
6:40 to 7                          NRC Presentation                                                 NRC
7 to 7:30                          Statements from Elected Officials                         Elected Officials
7:30 to 9                          Public Questions and Comments                          Public and NRC
9                                      Meeting Adjourn                                                    All
======================================================================================
See also (much of it a repeat of the above, as posted here and pasted in immediately below): https://www.nrc.gov/pmns/mtg?do=details&Code=20240943

Public Meeting Schedule: Meeting Details

Purpose

The U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) staff will discuss the NRC’s Restart Panel activities including licensing reviews and inspections for the Palisades Nuclear Plant potential resumption of power operations. Holtec Decommissioning Inc. (HDI) will discuss current and planned activities for the Palisades potential restart. The public is encouraged to ask questions about the NRC’s oversight pertaining to the potential Palisades restart.

 

Meeting Dates and Times
08/01/24
5:15PM – 9:00PM ET
Meeting Location
Grand Upton Hall at Lake Michigan College
2755 E. Napier Avenue
Benton Harbor MI
Webinar
Webinar Link:https://events.gcc.teams.microsoft.com/event/9c152468-a1b5-435d-a7b7-42fc02b33674@e8d01475-c3b5-436a-a065-5def4c64f52e
Webinar Meeting Number:288 874 034 845
Webinar Password:a7k7cQ

 

Contact
April Nguyen
(630) 829-9587

Ngola Otto
(301) 415-6695

Justin Poole
(301) 415-2048

 

Participation Level
Observation

 

NRC Participants
Office of Nuclear Reactor Regulation
Region III
Office of Nuclear Material Safety and Safeguards
Office of Nuclear Security and Incident Response
External Participants
Holtec International
Docket Numbers – Facility Names
05000255 – Palisades

Related Documents

ML24200A204 – 08/01/2024 HYBRID PUBLIC OUTREACH MEETING WITH THE U.S. NUCLEAR REGULATORY COMMISSION AND HOLTEC DECOMMISSIONING INC. ON THE POTENTIAL PALISADES NUCLEAR PLANT RESTART

 

Teleconference
Bridge Number: (301) 576-2978
Passcode: 110229600#
Conference ID:110229600

Comments

This meeting is hybrid (in person & virtual). The Open House will be held in person only from 5:15 PM to 6:00 PM ET, as it does not lend itself to the hybrid format. Members of the public, who are participating virtually can join the meeting at 6:00 PM ET. Register at least 30 minutes in advance of the meeting by clicking on the link provided above. The link will take you to a new page where you will be asked to provide registration information including an email address, so that the system can send the Microsoft Teams link for the meeting. You can also join the meeting by telephone using the Teleconference number provided. Please note that in-person attendees will be given priority to speak during the public questions and comments session.

========================================================================================

 

NRC Press Release (as posted here, and pasted in immediately below): https://www.nrc.gov/cdn/doc-collection-news/2024/24-021-iii.pdf
NRC NEWS
Office of Public Affairs, Region III
Lisle, IL 60532-4352
July 25, 2024
No: III-24-021
Contact: Viktoria Mitlyng, 630-829-9662
Prema Chandrathil, 630-829-9663
NRC Will Hold Public Meeting August 1 To Discuss Potential Restart of Palisades Nuclear Plant
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission will hold a hybrid public meeting that will include the agency’s update on the plant’s readiness to potentially resume operation and a presentation from Holtec International on restart-related activities.
The meeting will be held at the Grand Upton Hall, Lake Michigan College, 2755 E. Napier Ave., in Benton Harbor. Information for attending virtually or by phone can be found in the meeting notice.
Palisades permanently ceased operations in May 2022. In early 2023, Holtec International, the Palisades license holder, expressed interest in returning the plant to an operational status. The NRC created the Palisades Restart Panel to guide staff efforts to review, inspect, and determine if Palisades could be safely returned to operation.
The presentations will be followed by a question and comment session for attendees to engage with panel members on the NRC’s presentation. In-person attendees will be given priority to speak. Additional information on a potential Palisades restart can be found on the NRC’s website.

 

Support Beyond Nuclear

Help to ensure a safer, greener and more just world for all